Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

A Quantitative Theoretical Conceptual Framework for Evaluating the Effectiveness of Simulation

Ganesh Naik, Rangappa S. Ashi

Abstract


Background of the study: Pediatric IV cannulation is an integral part of modern medicine and is practiced in virtually every health care setting. Children have approximately half the number of usable veins than adults, but they have less accessible veins. Pediatric IV cannulation can be challenging. Nurses performing IV procedures in children should be skillful and knowledgeable in basic IV therapy applications. Simulation provides effective and efficient Knowledge and skills regarding pediatric IV cannulation. Objectives of the study are to: (1) To assess the pre-interventional knowledge of staff nurses regarding pediatric IV cannulation. (2) To assess the pre-interventional skills of staff nurses regarding pediatric IV cannulation. (3) To evaluate the effectiveness of Simulation on Knowledge and Skills of staff nurses regarding paediatric IV cannulation. Conceptual framework adopted for the present study was based on the Ludwig von Bertalanffy’s general system theory. Methodology: To achieve the objective of the study with Quantitative Evaluative Approach Pre–experimental one group pre-test and post-test research design was adapted for the present study. The subject was selected by applying Non–probability purposive sampling technique to participate in the study. The tool prepared for data collection comprised of Structured knowledge questionnaires and Modified Intravenous Cannulation Skills Check List. Data analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics appropriate to achieve the set of objectives. Results: The pre–test mean Knowledge score was ±6.26 and Standard Deviation (SD) ±2.04 whereas the post-test mean Knowledge score of was ±18.26 and Standard Deviation (SD) ±0.78. The calculated paired ‘t’ value was (5.59) higher than the table value of (2.05) at 0.05 level of significance. Hence H1 was accepted. The pre–test mean Skills score was ±10.33 and Standard Deviation (SD) ±2 whereas the post-test mean Skills score of was ±27.6 and Standard Deviation (SD) ±1.49. The calculated paired ‘t’ value was (5.86) higher than the table value of 2.05 at 0.05 level of significance. Hence H2 was accepted. Interpretation and Conclusion: The results of the study clearly indicated that, after introduction of Simulation technique, all the staff nurses (30)100% of them had adequate knowledge and skills scores which explains that Simulation technique was effective to increase the knowledge and skills of staff nurses regarding Paediatric IV Cannulation. Since Nursing is a practice discipline. The findings of the study revealed that in- service education for nursing staffs should always be plan with Simulation which helps the staff nurses to develop necessary confidence and competencies in any given procedure. So, Nursing staffs can be able to practice procedure properly.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Gil Z Shilamovitz; Pediatric Intravenous Cannulation; Background, Indications, Contraindications Medscape; 18 September 2017; Available from [https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/2008690-overview]

Lenora A. McWilliams, Ann Malecha; Comparing Intravenous Insertional Methods with Hepatic Simulators; Nursing Research and Practice;29 January 2017; Available from [https://www.hindawi.com/journals/nrp/2017/4685157/]

Angela Lee; Pediatric /Neonatal IV therapy; Available from [https://www.childrensal.org/

workfiles/Clinical_ServicesNursing_Ed/PediatricNeonatalI VTherapyandtest.pdf]

Mr. Ollie et.al; Simulation; Wikipedia; 22February 2019; Available from[http://en.Wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulation.cited 22February 2019]

Anita C. Reinihardz; Iris L. Mullins; Connie D Blieck; IV insertion simulation: Confidence, skill, Performance; Volume 10; 10 March 2015; Available from [http://www.nursingsimulation.org/article/S1876-13999(10)00165-9/]

Chadani Osti, Menuka Khadka, Deepa Wosti, Ganga Garunga; Knowledge and Practice towards care and maintenance of peripheral intravenous cannula among nurses in chitwan: Medical college Teaching Hospital, Nepal; 14 March 2019; Available from [https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002 /nop2.288]

Vallaree Anant Morgaonkar, Binoy Viresh Shah, Somashekhar Marutirao Nimbalkar; Educational intervention to improve intravenous cannulation skills in pediatric nurses using low-fidelity simulation: Indian experience; BMJ Pediatrics open;4 December 2017; Available from [https:// bmjpaedsopen. bmj. com/ content/bmjpo/1/1/e000148.full.pdf]

Monika Ravik, Anton Havnes, Tarunn Bjork; Exploring nursing students transfer of peripheral venous cannulation from skills centre to the clinical setting; Journal of Nursing Education and Practice; Volume No.5; 2015; Available from [http://www.sciedu.ca/journal/index. php/jnep/article/ view/ 5695]

Samah Abdelalla Mohammed, Howaida Moawad Ahmed; The Effect of Simulation Training on Nurses and Intern Nursing Students skill, Confident and Satisfaction Regarding Neonatal Resuscitation; Volume 5; September-October 2016; Available from [https://pdfs.semanticscholar. org/56c1/ fbda 767f404 7337253e64c0166adcc090bca.pdf]

Melba Sheila Souza, Ramesh Venkatesaperumal, Frieda S Chavez; Effectiveness of Simulation among Undergraduate students in the Critical Care Nursing; International Archieves of Nursing and Health Care; Volume 3;2017; Available from [https://www.researchgate.net /publication /322 157 5 01_Effectiveness_of__Simulation_among_Undergraduate_Students_in_the_ Critical_Care_Nursing]

Md. Anwar Hossain, 1 Md Imamul Arif, Md Monoarul Haque; Assessment of the level of knowledge and practice on intravenous cannulization among staff nurses of selected tertiary care hospital in Daka city; MOJ Public health; 28 June 2016; Volume 4; Available from [http://medcraveonline. com/MOJPH /MOJPH04-00095.pdf]

Eskedar Birhane, KalayouKidanu, Mekuriakassa; Lifespan and and associated factors of peripheral intravenous cannula among infants admitted in public hospital of Mekkelecity,Trigary, Ethiopia 2016; BMC Nursing;2017 June15Available from: [https://www.ncbi. nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles //PMC54 72887/pdf /12912_2017_ Article_227.pdf]

Chandaniosti Menuka Kadka, Deepa Wosti; Knowledge and practice towards care and maintenance of peripheral intravenous cannula among nurses in Chitwan Medical college Teaching Hospital Nepal; Nursing open;15 April 2019; Available from:[ https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi pdf /10.1002 /nop 2.288]

Sushil Vishnu Boraste MD; Knowledge, Attitude and Practices about Peripheral Venous Catheter among Junior Residents and Nursing Staff: A cross Sectional Study; Scholars Journal of Applied Medical Sciences(SJAMS);30-8-2018; Available from [http://saspublisher.com/wp-content / uploads/2018/08/SJAMS-68-3034-3037-c.pdf]

Dr. Virendra Singh Choudhary; Impact of Intermittent Saline Flushing in the Patency of Peripheral Venous Catheter among Clients in Selected Hospitals of District Muktsar, Punjab; International Journal of Nursing Education and Research;January-March2015; Available from [http://ijneronline.com /Abstract View.aspx? PID=2014-2-1-8]

Fwo Yi Tee, Christine SiewLan Low, Patricia Matizha; Patient Perceptions and Experience of Pain, Anxiety and Comfort during Peripheral Intravenous Cannulation in Medical wards; Topical Anesthesia, Effective communication and Empowerment; International Journal of Nursing Science 2015; Available from [http://article.sapub.org/10.5923.j.nursing. 20150502.01.html]

Swati Nema; Effectiveness of Peripheral Intravenous line with splint in neonates; admitted in NICU; International Journal of Recent Trends in Science and Technology; 26 March 2018; Available from: [https:// www. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov gov/pubmed/19439433]

S.Smith, P.Holder, K Leonard; Efficacy of a Five-minute Application of EMLA cream for the management of Pain associated with Intravenous Cannulation; The Internet Journal of Anesthesioogy; 2015; Available from[https://print. ispub. com/api0/ispub-article/8569]

Vijaykumar Gauttam; Jogindra Vati; A study to assess and compare the effectiveness of Moist Heat Versus Ice packs Application in Reducing the signs and symptoms of Intravenous Cannulation Induced Thrombophlebitis among patients admitted in civil Hospital Dausa District, Rajasthan; International journal of Applied Sciences; 2016;Available from[https://research- https://research-advances.org/index.php/IRAJAS/ article/view/229/239]

P. Sumathy, Mr Finny; A study to assess the risk factors of Developing Thrombophlebitis among children admitted in pediatric ward in selected Hospital at Puducherry; International Journal of Health Sciences and Research(IJHSR); 2016; Available from [https://rfppl.co.in/ subscription /upload _pdf /Aniciah%20 Marie%20Kuriakose_7948.pdf]

Vedavathi Hanumaiah, Eshanu H. Shastry; A study of Knowledge,attitude and practice of peripheral intravenous Cannulation among interns at Mc Gann teaching hospital Shivamogga: a descriptive cross sectional study; International Journal of Basic& Clinical Pharmacology; August 2020; Volume 9; Available from [https://www.ijbcp.com/index.php/ijbcp/article/view/4230]

Robert S. Jones, Angela Simmons, Gary L. Boykin Sr; Measuring Intravenous Cannulation Skills of Practical Nursing Students Using Rubber Mannequin Intravenous Training Arms; Military Medicine; November 2014; Volume 179; Available from [https://academic.oup .com/milmed /article/179/11/ 1361/ 4210 201]

Jose Manuel Hernandez, Jose Granero, Veronica; Effects of a simulation based workshop on nursing student’s competence in arterial puncture; Acta Paul Enferm; 11 November2016;Available from [https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/3070 307050383012_2.pdf]

Archana Nimbalkar, Dipen Patel, Amit Kungwani, Ajay Phatal; Randomized control trial of high fidelity vs low fidelity simulation for training undergraduate students in neonatal resuscitation; BMC Research notes open access;3 November 2015; Available from [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles /PMC4630885 /pdf/13104_2015_Article_162.3pdf]

TyseerMarzouk; Effectiveness of simulated delivery room classes on practical the achievement and satisfaction of maternity nursing students; Journal of Nursing Education and Practice; May 15 2014; Available from [http:// www .sciedu .ca/journal/ index.php/jnep/article/view/6697/4279]

Luciana Mara Monti Fonseca, Natalia Del Angelo Aredes; Computer and laboratory simulation in the teaching of neonatal nursing: innovation and impact on learning; Revista Latino-Americana de Entermegem; 16 Oct. 2016;Available from [http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid= S0104-116920 16000 10 0 418]

Joho AA; Mwampagatwa; Bolinga AE, and Kibusi S; The effectiveness of Simulation based training for life saving skills to improve Knowledge,skills and attitude of Nurses on caring mothers and newborn:Quasi experimental study; Journal of Pediatric and Womens Health Care26 Jan 2018; Available from;[ https://scienceforecastoa .com/Articles /JPWH - V1-E1-1003.pdf]

Constantinous Loukas, Nikolaos Niketeas; A virtual Reality Simulation Curriculum for Intravenous cannulation Training; Official Journal of the society for academic emergency medicine;Oct 2016; Available from[https:// www.ncbi .nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/21069896]

Asadollahi Maliheb, Jebraeili Mahanaz, Mohammadpoorasi Asghar; Comparing the effect of simulation and Vedio-based Education on mothers self efficacy in Bathing preterm infants; International Journal of Medical Research; 2016;Available from [https://www.ijmrhs.com/medical-research/comparing-the-effect-of-simulation-and-videobased-education-on-mothers-selfefficacy-in-bathing-preterm-infants.pdf]

Jacek Smereka, Lukasz Szarpak; A novel method of newborn chest compression; A randomized Crossover simulation Study; frontiers in Pediatrics;29 May 2018;Available from[https://www. frontiersin.org/article s/10.3389 /fped. .2018.00159/full]

Joseph O Connell, Gary Weiner; Intubating extremely premature newborns: a randomized crossover simulation study; BMJ Pediatrics open;5september 2017;Available from[https://bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com/ content/1/1/e000157]

Dr. Musthyala Manoj Kumar, Dr. Prakruthi Jaladhar, Dr. Mukhtarahamed Bendigeri; Assessment of intern’s Knowledge regarding peripheral Intravenous cannulation; International Journal of Science and Research(IJSR);2016 Available from [https://www.ijsr.net/ archive/v7i3/7i3/ ART2018848.]

Hanan Mohamed Soliman, Amany Mohamed shebele2, WafaaIsmaielShrief; Effectiveness of Simulation training on clinical Nursing Education and competence: Randomized Controlled trial; International Journal of Advanced Research; April 2014;Available from[https://bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com /content/ bmjpo /1/1/e000 148. full. pdf ]




DOI: https://doi.org/10.37628/ijnspr.v8i1.2047

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.